|
In the Occupied Territories, the people
I meet ask me many questions, but
there’s one they ask over and over again:
“Do they know? Do they know in Canada
what is happening to us?” My answer is
always no, but the more I see, hear, and
experience of oppression, the more vehement
my answer becomes: “They have
absolutely no idea what is happening to
you!”
“Then please tell them. Tell them
what Israel is doing to us. Tell them how
we live!”
7 July 2002 - Heathrow Airport,
London
For the last two months, I have been
working at Amnesty International in
London - where the world’s suffering is
documented, where pain from every corner
of the earth fills filing cabinets and
hard drives; reports and affidavits;
posters and press releases. The building
spills over with it.
After a year of university, buried in
abstract concepts, I went to Amnesty to
learn about the actual realities of people
without my privileges - my gender, my
skin colour, my money, my passport, my
luck. Despite six weeks worth of reading,
researching and learning, one phone call
showed me that I still didn’t get it. A
Palestinian doctor’s stories of terror and
atrocity tell me I have to go see for myself.
And now I’m at Heathrow, waiting for
my flight to Tel Aviv. Soon the pain will
come off the page and I will see it with
my own eyes. I wonder what the Israelis
and Palestinians I see around me are
thinking. Do they want to go home, or
do they dread leaving the safety of this
place? I can’t imagine feeling safer in a
foreign land than in my own home. I
can’t imagine having to leave home to
find security.
8 July 2002 - Jerusalem Hotel,
Occupied East Jerusalem
I have arrived but it wasn’t so easy to
get in. I was apparently identified as a
possible human rights or solidarity worker
so I resorted to my Jewish “half” to get
through. The security officers were
gorgeous women, mostly blondes. Was
their strategy to disarm me with their
beauty and charm, and then confuse me
by repeating the same questions again
and again? Despite my nervousness,
I managed to be convincing:
“I’ve come to see my homeland,”
I said.
“But why would you come at such a
dangerous time?”
“I don’t think it’s as bad as the papers
make it out to be,” I replied, trying not to
grit my teeth.
I’m surprised how calm I feel in a
place that has been illegally occupied for
thirty-five years. Relaxed was not what I
expected. So far, only one thing has really
shocked me. Up the street from this
hotel, a huge crowd of Palestinians is
gathered. They’re waiting to renew their
Jerusalem ID cards.
As permanent residents of Occupied
East Jerusalem, Palestinians have to
renew their cards every month, or risk
arrest and even imprisonment. This is the
only renewal office in the Occupied
Territories. Arriving the night before, the
people sleep in the street with their families,
waiting for the office to open in the
morning. Work, school, life - all are put
on hold as they wait for hours just to get
permission to live in their own homes.
I speak by phone with Sha’wan in
Ramallah. He is a human-rights
researcher with al-Haq, the Palestinian
human-rights organization I’ve come to
work for. We discuss how I will get to
Ramallah, just north of Jerusalem in the
West Bank. I’ll have to take my chances
with the military curfew that has been
imposed on the city for the last four or
five months. The curfew hours can
change every day and are completely
unpredictable. I will give it a try tomorrow.
9 July 2002 – Ramallah
When I leave the hotel, a bus is just
loading for the Kalandia checkpoint. The
bus fills up with locals, and I am frustrated
that I can’t speak with them. In their
sombre looks, I can see that they have stories
to tell.
The bus lets us off a few hundred
metres from the checkpoint, and I
approach on foot. There are soldiers
everywhere, behind concrete blocks, in
towers, in jeeps, or just walking around.
Concrete barriers litter the landscape. A
group of Palestinians are lined up, off to
one side. They look like ordinary people
just trying to go about their daily business.
Soldiers point and shout harshly at the
crowd. I have been taught about hate and
racism for as long as I can remember, but
nothing has prepared me for its stark reality.
The people are ordered about arbitrarily.
Move forward ten feet; then, move
back ten feet. The checkpoint is opened,
then closed again two minutes later.
Soldiers pull barbed wire around the
crowd. Then they open the checkpoint
again, but only for women and children,
leaving the men to bake in the sun.
I am mesmerized by the way these
conscripts, some just in their teens, flaunt
their M-16 assault rifles. They can’t keep
their hands off them. They hide their fear
behind wrap-around sunglasses. They
know what they are doing is wrong. I feel
sorry for them, men my age raised to hate
and oppress.
I get in line. Again they open the
checkpoint, and people are called forward
in groups of two or three. Each
group is questioned and the people asked
to show their papers. Some are pulled
aside for further questioning. Others are
told to pass through.
Then it’s my turn. “I’m going to visit
my friend Mike,” I explain. The soldier
looks at me, and then at my photo. “Do
you have a gun in your bag?” he asks.
“No,” I reply, surprised by his directness.
He waves me through, and I’m in the
West Bank.
Downtown Ramallah is full of people
trying to do their errands before the curfew
comes down. I meet Mike and he
takes me to the al-Haq office. Just inside
the building are the remains of the old
front door, blown in by the Israeli army in
the spring. Upstairs, the office door is in
the same shape. Mike tells me that the
army ransacked the office and stole documents
and files, as well as computers.
I meet Sha’wan, who introduces me to
Yassar, another al-Haq employee. Yassar
was there when the army turned up. He
was arrested and put in prison for two
months as an administrative detainee.
That’s a fancy way of saying he was never
charged or tried for any crime.
I meet the other staff, and we discuss
my assignment - editing English language
documents and writing a report. Then
we have to leave before the curfew comes
down. We buy some food and head for
the flat al-Haq rents for volunteers. As we
walk through the deserted streets, a
young man comes running towards us.
He says something in Arabic that I can’t
understand, but his tone is ominous. I can
hear the roar of diesel engines. Two
armoured personnel carriers come down
the hill towards us. Enormous loudspeakers
blare out that the curfew is now in
effect.
We arrive at the flat, which is much
bigger than I expected. I’m the only volunteer,
so I’ll have the place to myself. My
landlord speaks good English and insists
that I call her ‘Queen Elizabeth,’ much to
everyone’s amusement. She shows me
around and then we go out on the roof.
The view of the hills is magnificent. Back
inside, I ask where the Muquata, Arafat’s
compound, is. “Right there,” Queen
Elizabeth says, pointing out my bedroom
window. I can hardly believe it.
It's evening, and the sun has fallen
behind the dusty hills. Despite the curfew,
children are playing outside, on
streets scarred by the massive treads of
Israeli Merkava tanks. They ride bikes and
scooters, they play tag, and they fly homemade
kites. Whenever the army appears,
they dart behind their houses. The kites
dot the sapphire sky and all I can hear are
the cries of children and the rumble of
tanks and armoured personnel carriers in
the distance.
Tomorrow we will go to Sha’wan’s
home in the village of Sa’ir.
10 July 2002 - Sa’ir (near Hebron)
Sha’wan and I leave Ramallah just past
noon. In theory, the 40 kms to Sa’ir
should take an hour. However, since the
beginning of the Intifada, the trip can
take up to an entire day, or can’t be made
at all. Of course, Israeli civilians and settlers
still travel freely and quickly via
Israeli-only bypass roads.
Sha’wan doesn’t have a Jerusalem ID,
so we have to go around the Kalandia
checkpoint. We pick up a group taxi and
drive to the outskirts, then continue
along a makeshift dirt track and stop in a
field where a large group of other taxis
and people are gathered. Up the hill, I see
another similar group, and people walking
on a path between group. We follow
them and come to a huge trench, choked
by a massive role of razor wire. Planks of
wood and other materials have been used
to make a route over it and its deadly contents.
On the other side, we pick up our second
taxi, which takes us on similar dirt
tracks to the Jerusalem side of the
Kalandia. We’ve just skipped the checkpoint,
as thousands of Palestinians without
Jerusalem IDs are forced to do every
day. The Israeli army is fully aware of
these detours. They often block the
routes, but then sit back and watch while
the taxi drivers, trailblazers of the
Occupied Territories, create new ones. I
realize that I - or anybody else - can take
as many bombs into Israel as we want,
anytime, any day. Are these checkpoints
about security, or just oppression?
A third taxi takes us to the next
trench, another of the 120 roadblocks
throughout , which make trips like this,
formerly 45 minutes long, into three, five,
or ten-hour treks. We trudge down a hot,
dusty road, over one more trench, and
into yet another taxi. This, our fourth,
takes us through villages to a large olive
grove. We walk about a kilometre
through the grove, and cross another
large trench and clamber over a huge pile
of rubble, at least seven feet high. Then
we pick up our final taxi, into Sa’ir. The
trip has taken three hours, as fast as it can
be made if you’re Arab or with Arabs.
More often than not, checkpoints, roadblocks,
curfews, incursions or god knows
what, stretch the journey into an entire
day.
11 July 2002 - Sa’ir
In the evening, Sha’wan and his family
take me for a drive. The dusty mountains
glow like almonds in the sun, and terraces
covered in olive trees line their sides. The
orchards and crops run through the valleys
between them like leafy green rivers.
In the distance is the glimmering surface
of the Dead Sea and behind it, the
Jordanian mountains, which, like an
unfinished sketch, can be barely made
out through the dust of the desert.
We drive to the home of the family of
Osama, a sixteen-year-old boy who only a
month ago was shot in the head by Israeli
soldiers after he threw a rock at their
tank. He was on his way to school.
Needless to say, his family is devastated.
Osama was a top student, loved by his
family and his community. After the
soldiers shot him, they denied him the
medical attention that might have saved
him.
We sit down in the modest living
room and drink. Thick, flavourful Arabic
coffee. The families talk quietly. Osama’s
parents wear expressions of despair so
intense that I can hardly look at them. I’m
silent.
Osama’s family has made a CD-ROM in
his memory. It shows footage of Osama
receiving awards at school, of him as a
baby, and of his funeral. Arabic music
plays as the pictures scroll by.
Osama’s lifeless body, wrapped in the
Palestinian colours, moves across the
screen in slow-motion.
Osama’s mother tells me that when he
was killed, the world turned black for her.
She wants more than anything to visit her
own family in Jordan, but the Israelis
won’t allow it; nor will they allow her
family to come to her.
I realise that this is the first time I have
seen what true suffering looks like.
12 July 2002 - Sa’ir
In the afternoon, Sha’wan shows me
his grape vines and plum trees, just down
the valley from the house. Then he takes
me to visit a friend in the next village,
who keeps all kinds of birds, from chickens
to peacocks to ostriches. I notice the
massive bullet hole in his living room
window. It was made by Israeli troops,
who have a bad habit of firing randomly
in all directions.
As we walk towards the car to leave,
we hear gun shots in the distance. Using
his mobile phone, Sha’wan discovers that
Israeli soldiers have moved into the village.
We leave quickly, hoping to avoid
them. I sit in the back next to Manar,
Sha’wan’s older daughter. We speed
down a dusty dirt road until we meet
another car. The men in the car wave
frantically, telling us to turn back. An
armoured tank appears at the top of the
hill. I pull Manar’s head down with mine.
Sha’wan turns the car around quickly, and
we speed away.
Returning to his friend’s place, we discover
that a curfew has been dropped on
the area. We can’t go back to Sa’ir,
although it is only one village away. The
five-minute return journey from a visit
with friends, has become the difference
between life and death. We don’t know
how long we will have to stay; it could be
days.
13 July 2002 – Sa’ir
We want to return to Ramallah today,
but we get a call from Nasser, at al-Haq,
who tells us that the Israelis have moved
into Ramallah without warning, and are
using tear gas, and firing live ammunition
at people doing their morning shopping.
We decide to stay in Sa’ir.
This is simply routine for Sha’wan and
his family. In the blink of an Israeli general’s
eye, we have a new destination -
Hebron. We park the car at one of
Sha’wan’s friends, who lives near the
route to Hebron, now obstructed by a
massive roadblock. A steady flow of people
is climbing over the eight-foot-high
pile of rubble. Some haul goods in wheelbarrows
or carts; others pull children
behind them. One group tries to push an
old man in a wheelchair up one side and
down the other. We climb over and find
a taxi headed for downtown Hebron. We
travel through fields and villages and
make-shift dirt tracks.
The Hebron market is thriving, full of
shoppers. Sha’wan points to the top of a
small commercial building, maybe five or
six stories high, which has an Israeli
sniper nest on its roof that overlooks the
entire market. The shops opposite the
nest are completely covered in bullet
holes. Their signs are barely legible, and
their windows are held together with
tape. Why bother replacing them? It will
just happen again.
Zehi, a field worker for al-Haq, shows
me around. The buildings in the old city
have been occupied by Israeli “settlers”
since the late sixties. Their windows are
sandbagged, and a fortified bridge runs
over the street, between buildings. We
walk under a chain-link “ceiling” built
over the streets as protection from the
garbage and rocks colonists throw down
onto passers-by. We walk past the point
where a young boy once threw a rock at a
settler, who then shot him in the face
with a large-calibre handgun. The settler
received a small fine. I’m surprised to
learn that settlers (not just in Hebron)
carry M-16 assault rifles or large hand guns
at all times.
We walk through Hebron’s ancient
covered streets and then take a cab to the
remains of the largest Palestinian government
complex, built by the British after
they were given control of by the League
of Nations in 1922. This used to be the
bureaucratic backbone of Palestinian society.
It’s all been destroyed now, by the
order of Israel. The mass of broken concrete
and twisted metal could cover several
football fields, and is at least nine or
ten feet deep. The Israelis claim that the
compound had some connection to terrorism.
Are we to believe that the
destruction of Palestinian society is necessary
to stop terrorism? The windows of
the school across the street have been
blown in, and the classrooms are dark and
empty. Collateral damage. The Palestinian
flag flies sadly over the remains of the
compound. I stand on the wreckage of
Palestinian civilization.
Later, Sha’wan and Zehi take me to a
nearby refugee camp, one of the many
established in 1948, which has now developed
into a small town. The squalor is
shocking and the masses of children in
the street are filthy. They surround our
car to get a glimpse of me. We stop, and a
group of nine or ten-year-old boys jump
onto the running boards of Zehi’s old
pick-up truck. They smile and laugh at
me. One of them tries to grab my sunglasses.
They reach through the window
towards my camera. Sha’wan translates as
one boy lists seven or eight names of children,
his friends, that the Israelis have
killed. "We don't want peace," he says.
"We want to kill them, with their planes
and their Apaches and their tanks and
bombs and machine guns. We will
destroy Israel." His eyes glare through me
until I have to look away. It feels like this
ten-year-old boy has driven a hole
through my forehead. The boys ask me to
take their picture. How many of these
boys, I wonder, will be dead by the time
the film is developed.
In the evening we go to Zehi’s new
house to celebrate the fourth birthday of
Madleen, Sha’wan’s youngest daughter.
As we gather on the rooftop patio and
light the barbecue, the younger of the ten
children play and laugh, while the older
ones try out their English on me.
Piles of vegetables and lamb are
brought out and roasted. Arabic salads,
breads, hummus, olive oil, and yoghurt
surround me. Everyone gathers around
the barbecue, and we begin a feast few in
the Occupied Territories could ever imagine.
There is no table or cutlery; we eat
right off the grill, and it’s delicious.
We are quiet while we eat. Then, at
the approaching sound of a large diesel
engine, Sha’wan turns and mutters something
to Zehi in Arabic. “What is it?” I ask.
“Tank,” says Sha’wan. Everyone continues
eating. No one skips a beat. This foreign
occupation has become so normal that a
father doesn’t even reach to protect his
children when an enemy tank interrupts
the family barbecue.
1 August 02 – Ramallah
We’re past the second consecutive day
of 24-hour curfew in Ramallah. It’s been
fifty-five hours since we could leave our
homes without fear of being shot. Alone
in my flat, I’m really starting to feel it. I
watch the news over and over again. I try
to read. I call Canada. I eat a lot and take
naps. I clean the flat. If only I could switch
myself off. I’m suffocating, and I’ve only
been here for a few weeks.
Queen Elizabeth comes by to bring me
some good Arabic food. Today it’s rice and
meat with spices wrapped in grape leaves.
When I go down to return the plate, she
invites me in for a drink. We talk about
the Occupation and how it has effected
her family. She sighs the heaviest sigh I’ve
ever heard, and tells me about her broken
dreams and about her children, who have
no future. Once again, I’m silenced by
grief. There is nothing I can say.
In the evening, from my roof, I watch
the neighbourhood. Heavy-machine gun
fire interrupts the Beethoven violin concerto
I’m listening to on the portable CD
player. Below me in the streets, children
ride bikes and scooters and play ball. A
kite passes overhead, its tissue-paper tail
billowing in the wind, saying ‘shhhhh!’
Two Israeli helicopter gun-ships
appear overhead. The children rush to
find a kite, then pull it powerfully into
the air as if to do battle. The gun-ships
continue to circle. The sun is on its way
down, and the white of the stone houses
turns from gold to peach, then pink. Not
far away, in the remains of Arafat’s compound,
I can hear tanks and armoured
personnel carriers moving around.
Suddenly, a diesel engine roars much
closer. An approaching tank slows as it
turns onto my street, its turret swivelling.
The children dash down steps or duck
behind houses. I’m shocked that they
smile as they run. How exciting!! they
seem to say. They peer out as the tank
rolls by, shouting and clapping and waving
their hands. The crackle of gun fire
fills the air.
Darkness falls, and Israel sparkles, but
it isn’t beautiful. Sitting with the warm
Middle Eastern wind on my face, I think
of Sha’wan and try to imagine his life in
the Israeli prisons, where he spent eight
years without being charged or tried. I
imagine the look on his face when he was
released from prison, and then when he
saw his first-born son a full year after
birth. I remember watching Sha’wan’s
daughter, Madleen, playing with ducklings
in the garden. I remember her, in
the yard, playing with the ball I gave her,
while Israeli fighter jets flew low over the
village, again and again, like the jets that
killed nine children in Gaza only a few
weeks before. During the past two years,
the same military has killed two thousand
Palestinians, almost a quarter of
them children.
Madleen hardly seemed to notice.
When will we decide that the plight
of Madleen and others like her deserves
our attention? When will we give the
children of the Occupied Territories a
chance to play under a sky free of menace?
It’s time.
Peter Trainor is in his second year at University of
King’s College in Halifax, Nova Scotia. He remains in
contact with the people at al Haq.
This article is a condensed version of “Witnessing,”
originally published in The Coast, a Halifax weekly
newspaper (Vol. 10, No. 25, November 21 - 28, 2002).
|